posted by user: gulvarol || 4008 views || tracked by 1 users: [display]

Preregistration 2020 : NeurIPS'20 Workshop: The pre-registration experiment: an alternative publication model for machine learning research

FacebookTwitterLinkedInGoogle

Link: http://preregister.science/
 
When Dec 11, 2020 - Dec 11, 2020
Where Virtual
Submission Deadline Oct 7, 2020
Notification Due Oct 30, 2020
Final Version Due Nov 12, 2020
Categories    machine learning
 

Call For Papers

What is pre-registration and how does it improve peer review? Benchmarks on popular datasets have played a key role in the considerable measurable progress that machine learning has made in the last few years. But reviewers can be tempted to prioritize incremental improvements in benchmarks to the detriment of other scientific criteria, destroying many good ideas in their infancy. Authors can also feel obligated to make orthogonal improvements in order to “beat the state-of-the-art”, making the main contribution hard to assess.

Pre-registration changes the incentives by reviewing and accepting a paper before experiments are conducted. The emphasis of peer-review will be on whether the experiment plan can adequately prove or disprove one (or more) hypotheses. Some results will be negative, and this is welcomed. This way, good ideas that do not work will get published, instead of filed away and wastefully replicated many times by different groups. Finally, the clear separation between hypothesizing and confirmation (absent in the current review model) will raise the statistical significance of the results.

We are inviting submissions on the broad range of topics covered at NeurIPS! The paper template is structured like a mini-tutorial on the pre-registration process to get you started quickly. Pre-registered papers will be published at the workshop. The final results will be published in the Proceedings of Machine Learning Research (PMLR), a sister publication to the Journal of Machine Learning Research (JMLR).

Related Resources

Transformations 37   Transformations issue 37: Orbiting Otherwise: Alternative Approaches to Satellites
CVPR 2022   Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition
Alternative Incursions Anthropocene 2021   Beyond Modernity: Alternative Incursions into the Anthropocene
MLDM 2022   18th International Conference on Machine Learning and Data Mining
Print4Fab 2021   Printing for Fabrication Online 2021
CFDSP 2022   2022 International Conference on Frontiers of Digital Signal Processing (CFDSP 2022)
PAAMS 2021   19th International Conference on Practical Applications of Agents and Multi-agent Systems
FAIML 2022   2022 International Conference on Frontiers of Artificial Intelligence and Machine Learning (FAIML 2022)
The Cult of St. Olaf. 2021   The Cult of St. Olaf. Christian Identity in Pre-Reformation Scandinavia and the Baltic Region
DASFAA 2022   Database Systems for Advanced Applications